17 Comments
User's avatar
KB’s Musings & Observations's avatar

Whst a well written piece.

Natalia's avatar

Let's be honest. She rejected him because she wasn't interested, not because he was clear and talked about marriage early on. In fact, as a woman, I can say that a man who makes his intentions clear from the beginning is very attractive. But if she wasn't attracted to him or saw signs of immaturity, she wasn't going to give him false hope. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Alan Schmidt's avatar

A had a buddy who grilled his date for two hours on abortion, immigration, etc. She was a fellow Catholic and morally aligned but got so rattled she left the date shaking.

He didn't get another date.

John's avatar

If she got rattled, she wasn't all morally aligned.

John's avatar

Blaming the men again. Sigh. What a terrible column.

Counterpoint: given the degenerate state of society, marriage, and women today, Catholic men *should* ask these hard questions up front and clear out the chaff early. If you wait, playing footsie and developing attraction for someone, you risk asking these questions too late, when the attraction would override your good judgment.

Your advice here is designed such that Catholic men will fall in with unserious, uncommitted, lying, or otherwise bad women for marriage. Better to get the formal questions out of the way first so you can dismiss the women who don't measure up.

Patrick Neve's avatar

Young men are free to not follow my advice

We do need more priests after all

John's avatar

"If you don't do what I say you'll end up alone!"

Yes. Better that than a feminazi, baby-killing slut wife who divorce-rapes her husband after a few years and uses the kids as weapons.

Your advice is guaranteed to get good men caught up with trash women and then ripped asunder. This is the time for hyper-vigilance for Catholic men in the first world with women, not flirtation and dancing around major issues.

If a few women get their fee-fees hurt because "dating isn't romantic anymore" that's a price they can pay for not policing their own gender and behavior. But you're not blaming the women for their bad behavior leading to this, only attacking the men for responding protectively and logically. Your column is thus feminist in nature, and thus anathema to men.

Better to let 100 good women go by putting these questions up front than marrying 1 bad woman by delaying them. Men, protect yourselves, put the tough questions up front, and ignore Patrick's very bad advice!

Jon Wander's avatar

Pat, I mean this with all due respect.

Your article is absolute dog vomit meant solely to signal that you're a supporter of the modern practice of sacred prostitution over actual marriage.

"signals to the other person that you care more about finding a certain type of woman than getting to know this woman."

Literally the entire point of 'getting to know this woman' is to see if she is that type

Wife material.

If your church has little to none of that you need to look into the mirror and ask yourself what exactly you are doing to produce so many gardening tools and how God will address your part in it on Judgement Day.

Dating is dead. People like you killed it.

Rose Marie's avatar

This is such a great point. I notice another version of this consistently on dating apps; men making very strong generalized statements about highly complex and/or controversial topics on their profile. (It’s totally possible that women do this too—I’m not trying to pick on men here! I just only see men’s profiles because I am a #woman). For example, “I’m looking for a traditional woman”, “I want a traditional marriage”, “I want a feminine-minded woman”. Like you explain so well in this post, it’s highly possible that many women within conservative-leaning, Catholic/Christian circles also aspire to whatever it is that a particular man means by “traditional marriage” or “feminine woman” — however, those are such broad terms with such a wide variety of definitions and controversial associations in the 21st century, that they probably turn away a lot of actually-ideologically-aligned women. To some people “traditional marriage” evokes a pretty standard image of one-man-one-woman-til-death-do-us-part-healthy-interpretation-of-Ephesians 5-marriage…and to some people it evokes images of 1950s housewives and overbearing, controlling husbands. Or my personal favorite vague, ill-defined term— “traditional woman”—do you mean generally conservative, family-oriented, and God-fearing, or do you mean something highly specific, like a woman who bakes her own bread and sews her own bedsheets and only wears dresses and is a stay-at-home-daughter? Anyway, all of that to say, I think you’re right— all of these terms and viewpoints and belief systems need to be discussed thoroughly AT SOME POINT in the dating process, but NOT within the first few conversations that one ever has with a person, and even more so, definitely not through vague staccato sentences laced with highly-controversial terms on a dating app profile. We have enough obstacles between men and women these days, sowing division and thwarting us from entering into a Trinity-imaging, new-life-bearing communion of persons. Let’s do our best to avoid creating even more stumbling blocks for the other good, well-intentioned people out there!

Pyra Draculea's avatar

I guess the counter argument would be that if you wait to bring these major points of potential contention up you could spend weeks or months with someone you really wouldn’t want to be raising kids with and by then you may have already “caught feelings” and will try to make it work despite fundamental mismatches. Which is at best a waste of everyone’s time.

Hence the tea-reading sleight of hand on both sides.

As an example, last year I had a few messages on Hinge with a lovely gentlemen, but I noticed he mentioned wanting kids in his profile. We’re in our mid-40s so I asked how much he wanted them (a lot, as it turned out) and explained I’m too old for that so we wished each other well and that was that. Waiting to bring it up after several dates seems like it would have just been kinda mean.

Similarly, I think the ability to filter on an app by religion and politics is a good thing even if it seems like “quality shopping.”

That said, I’ve definitely seen some nasty ways to find stuff up or abrupt unmatches without explanation, which is rude. The girl’s response in the screencap is at least polite and respectful in saying she’s not what he’s after.

There’s got to be a graceful and happy medium.

Christina Madak's avatar

You know what would solve this? Men getting permission from parents first, go through the rigamarole with them, and then approach the girl with confidence that the parents raised her with values and she can trust he passed the sniff test. Just take those fears right out of the hands of the couple and give them to the parents to deal with.

/End dream world

D.C. Odell's avatar

I had a friend do this and the girl he liked utterly rejected him. It might have also not helped that he pulled up the diocesan rules on dating and read it aloud to her

Christina Madak's avatar

Yeah... I'm gonna go he missed the point of going to parents first

Nathan A. Kreider's avatar

Good article! I do wonder what their relation was beforehand (looks like a dating app?). This (usually) wasn't a problem before because we could assume that people around us shared similar cultural views, and a lot of women you might ask out were people you had known a bit about beforehand. I knew a lot about my wife before our first date because we had been Facebook friends for years. How much of this could be solved by encouraging more community involvement, making many friends, and then if there's a connection, consider asking them out?